I read this one over a few weeks to my daughter. She seemed absorbed. I know it's a classic and I enjoyed reading it, but I started to feel sadly that it might not have the same resonance as it did at the time it came out. It may have just been me and my daughter, but I don't think we felt the excitement of the idea of running away and living in a museum that I felt when I read it as a kid. I wonder if we have too much "adventure inflation" where normal kids taking a commuter train on their own is just not the same as being actual wizards who are sent to another world as every Netflix kids show seems to be about. Those are more my feelings than my daughter's because all I got from her was "it was good", though she was certainly quiet and listening during most of the reading and always "aaaawww"ed when I stopped.
I also didn't quite understand the main theme of Claudia running away and not wanting to return until she had achieved something. I mean I got the part that she ran away to be special, but the idea of her having a secret and that satisfying her was too subtle for my simple brain. I will be taking my daughter to the Museum of Natural History at some point, so we'll see if she remembers anything from the book.
No comments:
Post a Comment