Okay, it took this book to finally nail home my lesson about Ngaio Marsh. Her books are not relaxing, escapist fare! I brought this with me on a work trip, thinking I could use it in my free moments and on the plane to kill time. Instead I struggled with the opening, barely able to get through a page, sometimes even a paragraph before I got distracted or nodded off. This shit requires serious focus. You spend the whole opening on trying to understand the layout of a New Zealand sheep farm and manor (impossible for me to visualize and no map provided) and once you have given up on that, it's page after page of who went where among 6 different characters (at least there was a cast of characters, though only with their formal names and not all the different nicknames and titles that are used in the book and no relationship map which was also needed; which nephew!?) while they were looking for a lost brooch. What really made all this sleuthing nerdery even more difficult to follow is that none of the relationships or the setting and situation are established, so you have no context for any of it. For front-loading the mystery minutiae at the beginning I am going to have to blame the author. In general, though I just have to remember that Ngaoi Marsh's books though also including fun characters studies and interesting situations are still ultimately whodunnits of the highest order and require a level of concentration that I cannot bring to a book.
So basically, this set me back almost two weeks of reading. I finally got hooked in once I got back from my trip and actually finished it on another plane flight. There was some good here, the portrayal of the New Zealand mountains and the sheep farm (and the process and locations for the shearing) were really interesting and kept the pages turning. The slow revelation of the victim, the farm matriarch and local MP, who goes from strong, inspiring woman to quite nasty, even abusive manipulator is well done. It gets particularly dark with the story of the local lad with musical talent that she took under her wing. The murder is gruesome, or rather the disposal of the body, which is stuffed into a bale of wool and then compressed. In the end, the revelation, though, left me a bit cold. I think I am done with Ngaoi Marsh for a while.
No comments:
Post a Comment